Canon SX1 IS
Digital Camera Review
Sep 04, 2009
- By Steve Morgenstern
5
It looks like an innocent compact SLR, but the Canon SX1 IS is actually a paparazzi-pleasing ultrazoom in sheep's clothing, with a 20x zoom plus high-def 1080p video. For the same $600, though, you could buy a highly rated interchangeable-lens SLR.
| Top Point & Shoot Cameras |
|---|
|
The Nikon P90 is the low-cost choice among our reviewed ultrazooms, at just $400 for a 12-megapixel camera with 24x zoom. It has a 3-inch LCD that tilts up and down from a bottom hinge, though it doesn't fully pivot the way the Canon SX1 screen will. The Canon costs $200 more for a slightly shorter zoom and lower resolution (at 10 megapixels), but provides full 1080p video recording, where the Nikon is stuck in old-fashioned 640x480 movie mode. The Nikon comes with a rechargeable Lithium ion battery, a potential plus versus the AA-burning Canon, but if you invest in a set of rechargeable AAs you'll get more shots per charge with the Canon than the Nikon can deliver, plus the ability to buy off-the-shelf AAs if your rechargeables peter out while shooting.
Despite the Nikon's higher megapixel count, our still image lab test results favor the Canon by a significant margin in nearly every category (the P90 did turn in better scores for image noise). The Nikon image stabilization system was ineffective in our testing, a considerable stumbling point for an ultrazoom camera. And when it comes to continuous shooting, the Canon smoked the Nikon with 3 frames per second versus 1.36 fps. The Nikon does offer a much higher top ISO setting, though, with ISO 6400 at full res.
All told, the Nikon P90 isn't a bad camera for the price, but we far prefer shooting with the Canon.
| |
Comparison Scores |
| |
 |
 |
| |
Canon SX1 |
Nikon P90 |
| Price |
$599.99 |
$399.95 |
| Color |
14.44 |
12.94 |
| Noise |
8.74 |
9.17 |
| Resolution |
9.67 |
8.24 |
| Image Stabilization |
18.73 |
0.00 |
| Shot to Shot |
5.65 |
2.34 |
| Video Color |
10.93 |
2.45 |
| Video Sharpness |
6.02 |
0.36 |