Canon EOS 5D Mark II Digital Camera Review

Canon EOS 5D Mark II

Digital Camera Review

4.7 The full-frame, 21.1-megapixel Canon 5D Mark II aced our color accuracy and dynamic range tests, and captures 1080p movies with extraordinary quality. But it's not the perfect all-in-one still and video camera: there are still too many quirks.
Advertisement
Latest Camera Reviews
DSLR Point & Shoot
Samsung
NX10
Panasonic
DMC-TS2
Olympus
E-P1
Casio
EX-G1
Nikon
D300S
Panasonic
Lumix DMC-FZ35
Pentax
K-X
Sony
Cyber-shot DSC-TX5
Nikon
D3000
Samsung
TL500
Recently Viewed Products
$20
$648
$498
$33
Top DSLR Cameras
Max Price: $7500
$0 $1875 $3750 $5625 $7500
Filters
All
Canon
Fuji
Nikon
Olympus
Panasonic
Pentax
All
Consumer
Professional
Prosumer
1.Canon EOS 7D
Prosumer
$1,499
2.Nikon D300S
Prosumer
$1,469
3.Olympus E-P1
Consumer
$648
5.Nikon D5000
Consumer
$649
6.Canon EOS Rebel T1i
Consumer
$678
EOS 5D Mark II Prices
External Reviews
Steve's Digicams
Canon EOS 5D Mark II
The Digital Picture
Canon EOS 5D Mark II

Video: Color & Noise Summary  
Comprehensive video testing and analysis
by Jeremy Stamas and the staff of
x
x • Strong, accurate colors in bright light.
• According to our testing, the camera was off a bit with red and brown tones, but most colors were very accurate.
• Noise levels were good in bright light, although other DSLRs performed better.
 
x Design & Handling Page 12 of 21 Video: Motion & Sharpness x

Note: This review was updated on July 27, 2009, with additional video testing. This updated review reflects the changes to the 5D Mark II video capabilities enabled by the 1.1.0 firmware update, released June 2, 2009.

Video: Color Performance (12.68)


The Canon 5D Mark II produced very accurate colors in our testing. The camera measured a color error of 2.76, which is a good deal better than the rest of the video-capable DSLRs we've tested. It also managed a saturation level of 106.6%, so the colors have quite a bit of pop and look rather deep. Note: we did all our video testing on the 5D Mark II using a Canon EF 24-105mm f/4L IS USM lens. Click here for more on how CamcorderInfo.com tests color performance.

Color Accuracy Performance
Color Test Chart (above), Color Error Map (right)
The Canon 5D Mark II produced a color error of 2.76 and a saturation level of 106.6% in our bright light color testing. (The map on the right is a diagram of the color error. The length and direction of each line indicates how the camera processed each particular color while capturing video.)

The color error map above shows how well the camera did with each individual color patch in our test. The 5D Mark II did a terrific job with most colors, particularly greens and blues. It only ran into trouble with reds and browns, which is signified by the longer lines between the squares and circles in the color error map above.

The data above comes from our test with the 5D Mark II set to its standard color mode. Using the camera's other color settings will get you different results (as you can see below), and we found the Neutral color mode to produce the most accurate colors (a 2.53 color error according to our image testing software).

Canon 5D Mark II Color Modes
Sample still life in auto mode 100% crop in auto mode
Auto 100% Crop
Portrait 100% Crop
Landscape 100% Crop
Sample still life in Neutral Neutral at 100% crop
Neutral 100% Crop
Sample still life in Faithful Faithful at 100% crop
Faithful 100% Crop

As we stated earlier, the 5D Mark II produced more accurate colors than each of the video-DSLRs we've tested so far—the Canon T1i, Panasonic GH1, and Nikon D5000. It also had better color accuracy than the HF S100, a high-end HD camcorder from Canon. In fact, the 5D Mark II's color score is better than most HD camcorders are capable. Only a few models from JVC (the GZ-HD300 and HM200) have done better in our color testing this year.

Canon 5D Mark II Color Comparisons
Canon 5D Mark II Canon T1i
Panasonic GH1 Canon HF S100

We like how vivid and deep the colors look on the 5D Mark II. The Canon T1i actually had a slightly higher saturation level (110.3%), however, and you can notice their color differences in the comparisons below (specifically with the green and red patches). Both the Panasonic GH1 and Canon HF S100 had lower saturation levels than the 5D Mark II and their colors were noticeably less vivid in our testing.

  Close-Up Color Comparisons
   
  Ideal Canon
5D Mark II
Canon T1i Panasonic GH1 Canon HF S100
Red
  Ideal Canon
5D Mark II
Canon T1i Panasonic GH1 Canon HF S100
Green
  Ideal Canon
5D Mark II
Canon T1i Panasonic GH1 Canon HF S100
Blue
  Ideal Canon
5D Mark II
Canon T1i Panasonic GH1 Canon HF S100
Light Skin
  Ideal Canon
5D Mark II
Canon T1i Panasonic GH1 Canon HF S100
Dark Skin

 

Video: Color Score Comparison
brought to you by CamcorderInfo.com

 

Video: Noise Performance (11.19)


The 5D Mark II averaged 0.4775% noise in our testing. This is a very respectable performance even though it's a bit worse than what we saw from the rest of the video-capable DSLRs that went through our labs.Compared to the average consumer HD camcorder, however, the 5D Mark II's results were very good. Out of the video-DSLRs we've tested, the Nikon D5000 measured the lowest amount of noise, with only 0.1925%. Click here for more on how CamcorderInfo.com tests noise performance.

Video: Noise Comparisons
Canon 5D Mark II
100% Crop
Canon T1i
100% Crop
Panasonic GH1
100% Crop
Canon HF S100
100% Crop

The crops above do a good job showing off the sharpness capabilities of each camera and camcorder. All the models above have very good sharpness and all of the crops were taken from 1920 x 1080 HD video. The Canon 5D mark II appears a bit crisper than the cheaper Canon T1i, but its image appears slightly less sharp than the HF S100. The GH1 is also very sharp, but its image has some blur and aliasing towards the bottom of the vertical trumpet in the image above. The full data and results from our video sharpness test are available in the next section of this review.

Video: Noise Score Comparison
brought to you by CamcorderInfo.com

 

Advertisement