Canon EOS 5D Mark II Digital Camera Review

Canon EOS 5D Mark II

Digital Camera Review

4.7 The full-frame, 21.1-megapixel Canon 5D Mark II aced our color accuracy and dynamic range tests, and captures 1080p movies with extraordinary quality. But it's not the perfect all-in-one still and video camera: there are still too many quirks.
Advertisement
Latest Camera Reviews
DSLR Point & Shoot
Samsung
NX10
Panasonic
DMC-TS2
Olympus
E-P1
Casio
EX-G1
Nikon
D300S
Panasonic
Lumix DMC-FZ35
Pentax
K-X
Sony
Cyber-shot DSC-TX5
Nikon
D3000
Samsung
TL500
Recently Viewed Products
$460
$379
Top DSLR Cameras
Max Price: $7500
$0 $1875 $3750 $5625 $7500
Filters
All
Canon
Fuji
Nikon
Olympus
Panasonic
Pentax
All
Consumer
Professional
Prosumer
1.Canon EOS 7D
Prosumer
$1,499
2.Nikon D300S
Prosumer
$1,469
3.Olympus E-P1
Consumer
$648
5.Nikon D5000
Consumer
$649
6.Canon EOS Rebel T1i
Consumer
$678
EOS 5D Mark II Prices
External Reviews
Steve's Digicams
Canon EOS 5D Mark II
The Digital Picture
Canon EOS 5D Mark II

  Nikon D90 Comparison Summary  
xThe full-frame Canon 5D Mark II has a higher megapixel count, a body that’s both more rugged and far heavier, and, of course, a substantially higher price tag than the more consumer-oriented Nikon D90. For still photography, the D90 held its own in most image quality tests, though the 5D Mark II video mode proved superior.
x Sony A900 Comparison Page 18 of 21 Nikon D700 Comparison x



  Comparison Specifications
 
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
Price $2699 (body only) $999 (body only)
Dimensions 6.0 x 4.5 x 3.0 in./152.0 x 113.5 x 75.0mm
28.6 oz./810g
5.2 x 4.1 x 3.0 in./132 x 103 x 77mm
22 oz./ 620g
Resolution 21.1-megapixels   12.3-megapixels
Processor DIGIC 4   EXPEED
Sensor size/type 36.0mm x 24.0mm (35mm Full-frame) CMOS  15.8 x 23.6mm CMOS
Kit Lens EF 24-105mm f/4 L IS USM  AF-S DX Zoom-NIKKOR 18-105mm f/3.5-5.6G ED VR
Viewfinder Eye-level pentaprism, 0.71x magnification, 98% coverage  .094x magnification, 96% coverage
LCD TFT color, liquid-crystal monitor, 3 inch, 920,000 pixels  Super density, 3 inch, 920,000 pixels
Live View Quick mode (Phase-difference detection)
Live mode/Face Detection Live mode (Contrast detection)
Manual focusing (5x/10x magnification possible)
Manual focus
Autofocus: Face-priority, wide area, normal area
Shutter Speed 1/8000 to 30 sec., bulb  1/4000 to 30 sec., bulb
Burst Speed Max. 3.9 shots/sec.  Max. approx. 4.5 shots/sec
Autofocus 9 AF Points (1 Cross Type) + 6 AF Assist Points  11 focus points (including 1 cross-type sensor)
  Exposure Compensation   Manual: ±2 stops in 1/3- or 1/2-stop increments (can be combined with AEB)  ±5EV
 Noise Reduction   High ISO (three levels), Long Exposure  High ISO (three levels), Long Exposure
 ISO range   ISO 100-6400 (in 1/3-stop or 1-stop increments), expandable to ISO 50-25600   ISO 200-3200 (in 1/3, 1/2 or 1-stop increments), expandable to ISO 100-6400 equivalent
  Flash  External only  Retractable, auto pop-up flash
 Media Format   Still: JPEG, RAW (14-bit, Canon original), sRAW1, sRAW2, RAW+JPEG
Video: MOV
Still: JPEG, RAW (12-bit NEFl) RAW+JPEG
Video: AVI
  Movie Mode     Yes  Yes
 Media Type   CF, UDMA compatible  SD memory card, SDHC memory card
 Connections   USB, Video out, HDMI, WFT-E4A extension system  HDMI
NTSC
Hi-speed USB
 Other Hardware  No No

 

  Performance Score Comparison
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
Color 13.61 14.98
Long Exposure 9.87 10.8
White Balance 14.27 10.04
Noise 6.90 6.74
Resolution 8.55 10.47
Shot to Shot 3.81 4.44

 

  Video: Comparison Scores
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
Video: Color & Noise 23.88 N/A*
Video: Motion & Sharpness 19.59 N/A
Video: Low Light Performance 27.6 N/A
Video Features 20.25 N/A
CamcorderInfo.com Exclusive - Video testing on the Canon 5D Mark II is provided by CamcorderInfo.com, the world leader in camcorder and video reviewing.
*Note: The D90 was tested last year, using CamcorderInfo.com's old testing rubric.
Therefore, its scores and data for video are not comprable to the Canon 5D Mark II.

 

Performance
The hallmark head-to-head feature here is clearly video quality, and on that score the 5D Mark II proved superior in our testing for both resolution and color accuracy—in fact, the experts at our sister site, Camcorderinfo.com, said the results were comparable to a professional Canon camcorder, though some controls are lacking, particularly in maintaining focus on moving subjects. The one area where the Nikon video was superior was capturing high-speed motion, where the Canon suffered from some blurring and imprecision. When it comes to still photography, the test results in color accuracy and image noise were neck and neck, though the D90 outperformed the Canon in our resolution scores, and delivers 4.44 shots per second in burst mode to the Canon's 3.8.

Components
The D90 sensor provides 12.3-megapixel resolution to 21.1 megapixels for the 5D Mark II. For video shooting, the microphone input jack on the Canon is an important feature the Nikon lacks. For stills, the Nikon provides a pop-up flash and autofocus illuminator, which the Canon lacks. Screen quality is on a par for both cameras, and both offer HDMI out for connecting to an HDTV.

Handling
With lens attached, the D90 weighs about a pound less than the 5D Mark II, a very substantial portability difference, though we do prefer the deep, rubberized grip on the Canon to the more petite and plastic D90.

Controls
When it comes to light sensitivity, the Canon 5D Mark II far surpasses the Nikon; the Canon's highest official ISO is 6400 with an expanded range to 25,600, the Nikon tops out at an official 3200 and an expanded range to 6400. We prefer the easy navigation of the Canon menu system to the comparatively clumsy Nikon approach. Nikon does offer more hand-holding features for less sophisticated SLR users, including a selection of custom scene modes right on the mode dial and a built-in help system that serves as a surprisingly effective substitute for carrying the user manual.

  ISO Examples
  x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 50 x  
x  
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 100 x x
x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 200 x x
x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 400 x x
x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 800 x x
x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 1600 x x
x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 3200 x x
x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 6400 x x
x x
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 12800 x  
x  
  Canon 5D Mark II Nikon D90
ISO 25600 x  
x  

NOTE: The images above are not used in our testing or scoring, but are included here to show real-world examples of the differences between cameras at the various ISO settings.

Advertisement